15th Mar 2017

Gist reasoning tests involving Romeo & Juliet stories show cognitive disability among TBI patients
Share Button

Detecting cognitive impairment in TBI patients can be difficult. But now one study suggests that “gist reasoning” may be the key to identifying TBI patients who will struggle with cognitive disability in everyday life.

You may not realize it, but you use gist reasoning every day. When someone tells you a story, you may summarize it in your head. When you are preparing to cook a meal, you may develop a grocery list of items you need ahead of time. Or when you meet a person, you may create a profile for her in your mind to remember later.

TBI Interferes with Cognitive Gist Reasoning

People with traumatic brain injuries (TBIs) have difficulty with these sorts of complex cognitive tasks. Brain injuries can interfere with a person’s ability to solve problems, understand instructions, or even maintain friendships.

But this kind of cognitive disability has been difficult to detect using traditional neuroscience tests. Concrete “yes or no” answers often provide enough contextual clues for many TBI patients to get by. In fact, most traditional tests only detect 42.3 to 67.5 percent of brain injuries.

New Test Asks TBI Patients to “Get the Gist”

To improve those odds, Dr. Ahsa Vas at the Center for BrainHealth at the University of Texas Dallas has developed a new test that relies on gist reasoning. Rather than laying out concrete questions, the test asks TBI patients to complete four different tests that measure abstract thinking.

Vas explains using the example of Shakespeare’s “Romeo and Juliet”:

“There are no right or wrong answers. The test relies on your ability to derive meaning from important story details and arrive at a high-level summary: Two young lovers from rival families scheme to build a life together and it ends tragically. . . . You integrate existing knowledge, such as the concept of love and sacrifice, to create a meaning from your perspective. Perhaps, in this case, ‘true love does not conquer all.’”

Because gist reasoning tests require TBI patients to use multiple cognitive functions at once, they tend to more correctly identify cognitive disability. The study tested 70 participants, 30 of whom had a history of moderate to severe TBI over 1 year ago. The gist reasoning test, called the Test of Strategic Learning correctly identified 84.7% of the TBI patients.

Why Cognitive Disability Testing Is So Important

Whether a head injury is caused by a fall or an auto accident, its effects on everyday life can be dramatic. Some symptoms, like dizziness and nausea, are easy to track and treat. But cognitive impairment can mask itself as shock immediately after the injury. Then, later, a person may not realize that his TBI is behind his having trouble at work or problems keeping a romantic partner. Proper screening is needed to get TBI patients the treatment they need to better perform daily life functions.

David Christensen is a brain injury attorney at Christensen Law in Southfield, Michigan. If you suffered a TBI as a result of a car crash, contact Christensen Law for a free consultation.

Leave a Reply



Everyone at Christensen Law was extremely friendly and very easy to work with. Whenever I had a question, they took the time to talk with me and explained everything thoroughly. They were also very quick to return phone calls. I would definitely recommend Christensen Law to anyone in need of a personal injury lawyer.

I suffered Traumatic Brain Injury when struck by a vehicle while walking. My recovery was a long uphill battle; I had little energy to expend on daily routines and even LESS on caring for my home and life. I wondered how I could continue into the future with the difficulties I faced.

I handed the baton off to David and Sarah of Christensen Law. They resolved the unique challenges of my case while buffering me from the opposing side’s onslaught. The case concluded successfully and to my satisfaction with minimal effort on my part.

To ease the burden of the load you carry, make the decision on your legal team today. You’re in the right place – all you have to do now is make the call.

Overall a professional, great team. Everyone knew me and my case. When I left a message, I got a quick reply. Sarah made me feel comfortable going into a courtroom, where I never had been before. Both David and Sarah are very knowledgeable with legal issues. I trusted everyone and am a satisfied client.

V. Watkins

I never knew attorneys could be so accessible and kind. They fought for me all the way to the end. They had to take my case to trial and they won me a great settlement. Now I have a secure future.


HH, Davison

I was treated very nicely and professionally with a lot of consideration and compassion for my disabilities suffered in a horrible car accident. Mr. Christensen and Sarah Stempky made sure I understood what was happening with my case and that everything was pulled together.

LG, Stockbridge

As an accident victim I had to have my leg amputated and I was in bad shape overall. David Christensen was a light in that experience. I ended up with an entire home modification to accommodate my disabilities. It was a very stubborn insurance company but David wouldn’t take no for an answer.

CB, Milford

If I had questions or worries Dave would address them with me because he knows what he is doing. I think the world of him. I felt he went above and beyond to turn a really bad situation around. I have hope now where before I felt powerless and miniscule and that these big insurance companies were just going to railroad me.

DT, Jackson

Awards & Accomplishments